Fighting Overcriminalization in Federal Regulations
Signed: May 9, 2025
Published: May 14, 2025
Document Number: 2025-08681
📋Summary
This executive order aims to reduce the use of criminal penalties for violating federal regulations and to make any remaining criminally enforceable rules easier for the public to find and understand. It affects federal executive agencies, the Office of Management and Budget, and the Department of Justice, and it indirectly affects individuals and businesses that could face criminal liability for regulatory violations. Agencies must, within a year, publish and regularly update a public list of all regulations they enforce that carry criminal penalties, including the possible penalties and the required state of mind (what a person must know or intend) to be convicted. Criminal enforcement is strongly discouraged for any criminally enforceable regulation that is not included in an agency’s published list, and agencies and DOJ are directed to weigh whether a rule is on the list before making referrals, opening investigations, or bringing cases. Going forward, agencies are told to clearly label proposed and final rules that could trigger criminal penalties, identify the legal authority, spell out the required state of mind in the rule text, and treat strict-liability criminal rules as disfavored and subject to heightened review.
💼Business Impact
This order most affects heavily regulated industries that face criminal exposure for technical violations—healthcare and life sciences (FDA/HHS), financial services (SEC/FINRA-adjacent federal rules), environmental/energy (EPA), transportation/logistics (DOT/FAA/FMCSA), government contracting, and import/export/trade compliance (CBP/BIS/OFAC). It signals a shift away from “gotcha” criminal cases toward civil/administrative enforcement unless the government can show knowing/willful misconduct, and it creates a near-term opportunity to reduce risk by using the forthcoming agency “lists� of criminally enforceable regulations (and their mens rea standards) to prioritize compliance controls and training around the highest-penalty, highest-harm areas. Compliance requirements will likely become more explicit in new rules (agencies must label rules with criminal consequences and state mens rea), while strict-liability criminal provisions should face higher internal review—potentially slowing or narrowing new criminally enforceable regulations. Immediate actions: (1) assign an owner to monitor your key regulators’ Federal Register guidance (due ~45 days) and the public criminal-offense inventories (due within 12 months), (2) refresh policies/training to document “knowledge
Full Text
Due to aggressive automated scraping of FederalRegister.gov and eCFR.gov, programmatic access to these sites is limited to access to our extensive developer APIs. Please visit FederalRegister.gov API documentation or eCFR.gov API documentation to learn more about how to access the API.
Your request has been flagged as potentially automated. If you are human user receiving this message, please complete the CAPTCHA (bot test) below and click "Request Access". You may occassionally be asked to complete the CAPTCHA again, this is normal and part of our security measures.
An official website of the United States government.
If you experiencing issues with the CAPTCHA or want to request a wider IP range, you can use the "Site Help" button found in the lower, right of this page to make a request.